"If there is something you don't like doing, push yourself to do more of it".
That piece of advice, given by one of my former supervisors, has stuck with me for years.
And they weren't wrong. Doing more of the things you don't like makes them less scary. And you learn how to prepare for them.
For me, that thing was giving presentations.
Or more precisely, the part that followed them. The presentation itself I could prepare for: research the topic, write my notes, work on my delivery. Like many introverts, I'm most comfortable when I've had time to prepare.
The scary part was the bit that came afterwards. The Q&A.
A Q&A opens the floor to the audience. To ask about the issues that matter to them, not the ones you've chosen to focus on. It's the one part of a presentation which you can't script.
And when you're still building your expertise, the Q&A can leave you feeling exposed. You want to be able to answer whatever's thrown at you, and there are only so many times you can say that you'll "take that question away".
Exposed
A few years ago, I was part of a team delivering a presentation to a client.
I'd prepared thoroughly, using notes from a colleague who had delivered a similar presentation the year before, as well as my own research. On a general level, I knew the topic well. But there were areas I hadn't yet come across in practice. One of them was taking security over certain farming assets. I'd read up on it, but never advised on it.
It took up half a slide in a 30-slide presentation.
I'm sure you can guess what topic came up in the Q&A.
"This is a question for Sam".
Forty faces turned towards me. Gulp.
I gave the best answer I could. Then one of my more experienced colleagues stepped in with, "To just build on that...", quietly filling in the gaps without making a point of it.
Yet, I felt exposed. It felt as if the whole room had just realised I didn't know the topic I was presenting on.
Looking back, I'm sure no one gave my knowledge of that niche point a second thought. But the experience stayed with me. Every Q&A since has carried the same fear.
What if they ask about the one thing I don't know?
Using AI as a sparring partner
What I didn't have back then, but do now, is a sparring partner. Someone to throw the hard questions at me before the audience does.
I use AI for this (always a tool approved by my firm). I ask it to question me as if it had just sat through my presentation. To do that, I:
- give it my presentation notes and slides, along with the context of why the presentation is being given and to whom;
- point it to reliable sources on the topic, particularly the niche areas; and
- ask it to play a member of the audience.
My prompt usually looks something like this:
"You work in [industry], with a specialism in [niche area]. I'm about to deliver the presentation in the attached [notes/slides] to you. Please review it, along with [sources] on [niche area]. Then ask me five questions you'd want answered as a member of the audience, on points that need clarification or more depth. Ask one question at a time, and wait for my answer. If the answer is incomplete or unclear, please follow up before moving on."
Five questions is, of course, just my preference. But it's a manageable number and keeps the focus on the core points.
Asking for one question at a time matters more than the total number asked. It mirrors a real Q&A, where you have to answer what's in front of you, rather than skimming a list to pick out the easy ones. It also stops you feeling overwhelmed by a barrage of questions.
Because the AI can follow up, it presses where your answer is thin, just as a sceptical audience member would. You quickly find out where you hesitate.
And that's exactly the point. You find the gaps in private, rather than in front of forty people. Had I been able to do this years ago, I suspect a question on farming assets would have come up in preparation first, rather than in the room.
Then I go back to the questions I stumbled on and prepare for them. That's where introverts are strongest. The sparring session just shows us where to focus.
How to say "yes" more often
More recently, I've used this approach for another presentation.
Sure enough, one of the questions in the Q&A was along similar lines to one the AI had asked me. I'd already worked through the answer, so rather than scrambling, I could answer with confidence.
Let's be clear. The fear has not gone, and I can still feel it when the floor opens up. But it's smaller now, and smaller is enough.
I'm more willing to put my hand up to help out with presentations. That means more Q&As, which is exactly what my supervisor suggested doing all those years ago.
It's also worth noting that the AI isn't answering the questions for me. It's asking them. The thinking is still mine. And every round is another way to build upon the knowledge I'll draw on when there's no time to prepare.
So don't wait for the room to find your gaps. Find them first, and do more of what you don't like (in private).
That way, the hardest questions shouldn't be a surprise.