Over a decade ago, and after numerous applications, I was invited to attend an assessment day at a top law firm.
Finally, this was my chance to be a lawyer. All that stood between me and the prospect of getting a much sought-after placement was an individual case study, a group exercise, and an interview.
I had spent weeks preparing. Finding every resource that I could. I'd bought a new suit and a red tie.
In both the case study and the group exercise, I read the scenario over and over again. Looking for the questions I thought I was going to be asked. Looking for the traps that would make it easy for them to throw my application on the "no" pile.
When the questions came in the case study, I missed the core points.
And while I had views in the group exercise, I wanted to make sure they were correct before offering them up. So, I never actually offered them up.
A week later, I received the email. They regretted to inform me that my application would not be taken further.
The feedback? I had been with them for an entire day, but they just hadn't heard enough from me.
Feedback is golden
At the time, I was devastated. I thought I'd blown my shot.
But thinking back, the feedback was golden. Not because it was kind. Because it existed at all.
The pattern doesn't stop upon qualification. It just stops being pointed out.
The replay
Fast-forward several years. A qualified lawyer building my experience and practice.
I was asked to review a document for a client. I kept circling back to the same, poorly drafted clause put in place many years beforehand.
I was trying to make sense of it. Interpreting it in several different ways. Looking for certainty where there was none.
I'd spent days stuck on this one issue. Searching through volumes of commentary and court decisions to try and find how the drafting would be interpreted. Time that I didn't have.
It didn't feel like paralysis. After all, clients look to us for clarity when issues are murky.
Yet I'd fallen into the same trap that I had years before. It was paralysis, dressed up as rigour. And this time, nobody told me.
Stop answering the wrong question
I was fortunate that, on this occasion, I had the opportunity to step away and sleep on the issue overnight.
I awoke with a clarity of thought.
And while the easy thing would be to conclude that sleeping on an issue was the answer, the night didn't actually solve anything. It stopped me. And it was luck that I had enough slack in the deadline.
Once I'd stopped, a different question surfaced. I'd spent days asking myself what the provision meant, instead of what the client wanted us to resolve.
It was the same error I made back at the assessment day. They asked me questions about the case study, and I answered what I thought was buried in it.
On that occasion, I didn't have a night. I had 20 minutes followed by a room with two people in it. What I needed then, and what I need at 4 pm on a weekday isn't a night's rest.
So, if you find yourself stuck in a loop. Going around in circles. Try asking yourself, what is the question I have actually been asked?
Knowing the pattern shortens the recovery
I'd love to say that experience completely breaks the habit of overanalysing the wrong question.
Yet, in reality, it doesn't. I was told exactly what I was doing at the assessment day a decade ago, and it still cost me days on a single provision. Experience doesn't make you immune. It simply shortens the recovery.
So while I may be more experienced, I still have to break the habit manually. With a question I can ask myself while the document is still open.
Somewhere on your desk is a question you've been answering for days. It may not be the one you were asked.